The short answer
Does home warranty cover water damage? Not in the 3 sample contracts read here: American Home Shield, First American and Choice undertake to repair the leaking line or failed appliance and open a wall to reach it, not the ruined floors, belongings or mold. California and Florida statutes keep that consequential damage out of these contracts, leaving it a question for a homeowners policy.
Where do three real contracts draw the line between the pipe and the wet floor?
All three pay for the line and refuse the water’s aftermath, with different wording. The columns below quote the American Home Shield sample Plan Agreement (form RENA24, copyright 2024), the First American California sample contract (form CS3T 03/24; its Texas sample matches on the leak line) and the Choice Home Warranty user agreement, which is the live web text rather than a dated sample. American Home Shield states the practical result on the American Home Shield plumbing page: "we do not cover secondary damage like warped floors from the dishwasher flooding your kitchen. That likely falls under homeowners insurance coverage."
| Clause | American Home Shield | First American | Choice Home Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leak repair | "Leaks or breakages of water, gas, drains, waste or plumbing waste vent lines and pipes that occur within the Covered Home" | "Leaks and breaks of water, drain, gas, vent or sewer lines (except caused by freezing)" | "Leaks and breaks of water, drain, gas, waste or vent lines." |
| The damage the water does | Section 7.F: no payment for "special, secondary, incidental, indirect, consequential, exemplary, or other related costs or damages", including "personal and/or real property damage" | Limits of Liability, item 4: not responsible for "consequential, incidental" damages, "secondary damage, loss resulting from the malfunction of any Item" | Section E: you waive "indirect, punitive, incidental, consequential" and "any other damages, other than for actual out-of-pocket expenses" |
| Opening the wall | Access "through one layer of unobstructed drywall" and return "to a Rough Finish" | Access through unobstructed surfaces, returned to "a rough finish (Rough Finish Only)" | Up to $500 for access, returned "to a rough finish condition" |
| Finishes | Section 7.A: no pay for "construction, carpentry, restoration" | Item 7: will not "refinish or replace cabinets, countertops, tile, paint, wall or floor coverings or the like" | No separate clause found; rough finish limit applies |
| Water by name | Section 7.L lists "freezing, and flood" and "water damage" as causes it will not cover a breakdown from | Roof section: "SECONDARY OR CONSEQUENTIAL WATER DAMAGE IS NOT COVERED BY CONTRACT." | No sentence naming water damage found; rests on the Section E waiver |
| Mold | Section 7.S excludes "mold, mildew, bio-organic growth, rot, fungus" | Item 8: no claim arising from "any pathogenic organisms", defined to include "mildew", "fungi, mold" | The word mold does not appear in the agreement text retrieved |
Choice reads differently from the other two. The waiver in Section E of the Choice Home Warranty user agreement sits beside language about service providers and carves out "actual out-of-pocket expenses", and we found no line that names water damage. Before relying on that gap, ask Choice in writing whether out-of-pocket expenses include drying or flooring after a covered leak, because Section A calls arranging a Service Provider to repair or replace a Covered Item its "sole responsibility".
Why can’t a warranty just pay for the wall? California and Florida write it out
In at least two states the exclusion is the legal definition, not only a company choice. California Insurance Code 12740(a) defines a home protection contract as repair or replacement necessitated by wear and tear, deterioration or inherent defect, and says it "shall not include protection against consequential damage from the failure of any component, system or appliance." Florida Statutes 634.301(2) goes further: paying consequential damages "constitutes the transaction of insurance subject to all requirements of the insurance code."
So a sales promise cannot stretch a contract under California’s 12740 or Florida’s 634.301, and a plan advertised as a best home warranty for water damage should prompt one question: which clause, by section number, pays for the flooring? Other states regulate these contracts differently, so ask your state insurance department who licenses home warranty companies there and where a complaint goes.

Who pays in six common leak scenarios, the warranty or an HO-3?
The insurance column quotes ISO HO 00 03 05 11, the standard form, plus the USAA HO-3R form filed in Oklahoma and the HO 04 95 endorsement summary where noted. It describes form language and does not tell you what your policy pays, since carriers file their own versions. Ask your agent which water endorsements you hold and how your form treats seepage. The wider claim is covered on does homeowners insurance cover water damage, and a tank failure on water heater leak damage.
| Scenario | Warranty samples | ISO HO-3 language |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Supply line bursts behind drywall | Line repaired; opening left at rough finish. Burst from freezing is treated separately in row 5. | Exception to c.(6) reaches resulting loss to the building and "the cost to tear out and replace" what is necessary to reach the system, but "We do not cover loss to the system" itself. |
| 2. Under-sink drip for weeks | Leak repaired if on a listed line. Mold and rot excluded (AHS 7.S; First American item 8). | ISO lists wear and tear and limits mold to hidden mold. Carrier forms can add more: the USAA form excludes seepage "over a period of 14 days or more". |
| 3. Water heater tank fails | First American: not on Starter, $1,000 limit on Essential, limit removed on Premium. AHS lists the tank. Choice lists units up to 75 gallons. | Peril language leaves out loss "to the system or appliance from which the water or steam escaped"; the floor below is the question to ask. |
| 4. Dishwasher overflows | Machine repaired if your plan lists it. AHS ShieldEssential lists no appliances; ShieldPlus and ShieldComplete do. Warped floors are out, per AHS’s own example. | "Household appliance" is inside the accidental discharge language; the machine itself is not. |
| 5. Pipe freezes and splits | First American excludes leaks "caused by freezing"; AHS 7.L lists freezing. Choice has no freezing line in its plumbing section. | Conditioned on reasonable care to "Maintain heat in the building" or "Shut off the water supply and drain all systems". |
| 6. Sewer or drain backs up | Stoppage cleared within 100 feet (AHS, Choice) or 125 feet (First American); roots excluded. Cleanup is out. | Exclusion A.3.b removes water that "Backs up through sewers or drains"; endorsement HO 04 95 adds a scheduled limit back. |
Row 6 is why a backup can leave a gap on both sides, and the renter’s version of that endorsement is explained in water backup coverage for renters. A frozen or burst line has its own repair page at burst pipe repair.
How much will a warranty spend to reach a pipe in a concrete slab?
Often $1,000 or less, and on some tiers nothing. The First American California sample contract excludes items in or under concrete on Starter, then caps the work at $500 on Essential and $1,000 on Premium. The American Home Shield sample Plan Agreement allows up to $1,000 for concrete access and rough finish, rerouting included. Choice sets a single $500 access limit that also covers walls, floors, ceilings and roofs, inside a $3,000 yearly limit per Covered Item.
What does a leak call cost you: service fee, trade call and cap?
Only the American Home Shield sample Plan Agreement prints a figure in its sample, $100 or $125, so the other two fees must come from your own summary page. A homeowners deductible, if you make a claim for the resulting damage, is a separate cost under a separate contract.
| Term | American Home Shield | First American | Choice Home Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service fee | $100 or $125, stated in the Plan Summary; non-refundable | Disclosed on your summary page; due per Trade Call | Set in your Coverage Details; paid to the provider per request |
| Same item fails again | Second opinion costs another fee, refunded if the ruling reverses | No new fee for repeat visits on the same item; work warranted 30 days | Failure within 30 days fixed with no new fee |
| Overall cap | $50,000 for all claims in the initial term, then per 12 months | "any dollar limit mentioned is in the aggregate"; no plan total found | $3,000 per 12 months per Covered Item, unless lower |
| Roof leak add-on | $1,000; optional except on ShieldComplete | $1,000; included on Premium | $500; optional |
| When cover starts | Stated in the Plan Summary | Contract Effective Date, 12 month term | 30 days after the fee, sooner with proof of prior cover |

Will the warranty plumber arrive before EPA’s 48-hour drying window closes?
Plan as if not. EPA says to clean and dry wet spots within 48 hours, while the First American California sample contract promises to initiate services within 48 hours, and Choice Home Warranty user agreement warns "it could take more than 48 hours for a Service Provider to accept the request." The American Home Shield plumbing page says a contractor reaches out within 24 to 48 hours. None of those clocks starts the drying, and the contracts do not pay for it.
So the sequence runs in parallel. Shut off the water at the valve and photograph the failed part before anyone touches it. Open the warranty claim for the leak. Give your insurer notice for the damage: ISO HO 00 03 05 11, Duties After Loss, asks for "prompt notice" and that you "Protect the property from further damage" and keep a record of repair expenses. First American also requires that you "take reasonable measures to prevent secondary damage", so waiting for its plumber is not a safe plan.
Ask the warranty company two things on that first call: will an emergency plumber I hire be reimbursed, and do you need prior approval? The Choice text says it "will not reimburse for services performed without prior approval", and First American requires approval in advance for out-of-network work. Extraction is a separate trade, explained in what water mitigation is.
What should you compare if you want the best home warranty for water damage?
We do not rank companies, and no sample read here pays for the water damage itself, so the useful comparison is about the leak repair. Pull the sample for your state and check these six lines against the tables above, then route the damage question to your policy through our insurance hub.
- Freezing: First American’s leak line excludes it in print. Is it excluded on the plan you are quoted?
- Concrete: $0, $500 or $1,000 in these samples. What does your slab or basement floor plan pay?
- Water heater: First American’s Starter omits it. Is the tank itself covered, and at what limit?
- Appliances: AHS ShieldEssential lists none. Is the dishwasher or washer that could overflow on your plan?
- Waiting period: Choice’s is 30 days. When does cover begin on a monthly plan?
- Fee per trade: is one leak with two visits one fee? First American’s Trade Call clause says repeat visits on one item carry no new fee.
Questions people actually ask
Will home warranty cover a burst pipe?
The pipe repair, usually, and the wet room, no. First American’s sample covers leaks and breaks of water lines except those caused by freezing, and American Home Shield’s section 7.L lists freezing among causes it will not cover. Resulting damage is excluded in both. Ask what caused the split before the claim is filed, since the plumber’s written cause decides the outcome.
Does a home warranty cover mold after a leak?
Not in these samples. American Home Shield’s section 7.S excludes repair costs related to mold, mildew, rot or fungus, and First American’s item 8 excludes claims arising from pathogenic organisms, including mold. Choice’s agreement does not mention mold. On an ISO HO-3, resulting mold is limited to hidden mold from a covered discharge, so ask your agent about any mold sublimit.
Is a home warranty the same as homeowners insurance?
No. California Insurance Code 12740 describes a home warranty as a contract to repair or replace a component, system or appliance after wear and tear, with no consequential damage protection. An ISO HO-3 insures the dwelling and contents against direct physical loss, subject to exclusions. The two can sit side by side, because one addresses the failed part and the other is where resulting damage is claimed.
Does a home warranty cover flooding?
No sample read here does. American Home Shield’s section 7.L and First American’s item 2 both list flood among causes of breakdown they will not cover, and neither pays for the resulting damage. Exclusion A.3.a of ISO HO 00 03 05 11 removes flood and surface water too. A flood policy is a separate contract, so ask your agent about the National Flood Insurance Program.
Does a home warranty cover water heater leak damage?
It may cover the heater, not the damage. First American’s sample omits water heaters on Starter and limits Essential to $1,000. Choice lists units up to 75 gallons. American Home Shield lists the tank in its plumbing category. All three refuse resulting floor or wall damage, and an ISO HO-3 leaves out the appliance itself while addressing resulting loss.
Sources
- American Home Shield sample Plan Agreement, American Home Shield Corporation, form RENA24, copyright 2024, real estate plans, general states version. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- American Home Shield plumbing page, American Home Shield, FAQ answers on secondary damage and scheduling. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- First American California sample contract and Texas sample, First American Home Warranty Corporation, form CS3T 03/24, versions GCA.B and GTX.B. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- Choice Home Warranty user agreement, Choice Home Warranty, Terms of Service Agreement web text, undated. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- California Insurance Code 12740, subdivision (a), Home Protection Contracts. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- Florida Statutes 634.301, subsection (2), definition of home warranty, Florida Legislature. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- ISO HO 00 03 05 11, Insurance Services Office form, copy hosted by the Maine Bureau of Insurance. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- USAA HO-3R form filed in Oklahoma, Homeowners 3R(02) special form, Oklahoma Insurance Department filing. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- HO 04 95 endorsement summary, InsuranceXDate forms reference, description of ISO’s water back-up endorsement. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- EPA, Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings, Chapter 2, US Environmental Protection Agency, page updated 8 September 2026. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
- We read published sample contracts and forms, and did not obtain a live quote or file a claim. Our methodology sets out the standing rules.
This page describes contract and form language. It does not say what your warranty or policy provides or pays. Read your own documents and ask your state insurance department or a licensed professional the questions above.
